Barry Asks for Same-Sex Marriage Vote Back

DC Council votes 12-1 to recognize other states' same-sex marriages

View Comments ()
|
Email
|
Print

    NEWSLETTERS

    AP
    I voted for what?!

    WASHINGTON -- After the D.C. Council apparently voted unanimously to recognize same-sex marriages Tuesday morning, Councilman Marion Barry took his vote back, according to Washington Post reporter Tim Craig.

    Apparently Mayor for Life, an opponent of the legislation, voted yea without knowing but asked that the bill be reconsidered, and the debate that was expected took place, to the relief of all the council members who wanted their two cents on the matter on record.

    DC's Gay Marriage Recognition in Congress' Hands

    [DC] DC's Gay Marriage Recognition in Congress' Hands
    After Mayor Adrian Fenty signs D.C.'s same-sex marriage recognition bill, it will be up to Congress to strike it down. (Published Tuesday, May 5, 2009)

    Barry didn't vote the first time because he had walked away during the vote, he told the Post, but the initial 13-0 county indicated he was present.

    After an emotional debate, a second vote was taken, and it passed 12-1 with Barry as the lone opponent. Now it's up to Congress, which has final say over the city's laws and will subject the bill to a 30-day review after Mayor Adrian Fenty signs it as expected.

    DC's Gay Marriage Recognition in Congress' Hands

    [DC] DC's Gay Marriage Recognition in Congress' Hands
    After Mayor Adrian Fenty signs D.C.'s same-sex marriage recognition bill, it will be up to Congress to strike it down. (Published Tuesday, May 5, 2009)

    If Congress takes no action, the bill will become law automatically. President Barack Obama and congressional leaders have not signaled where they stand on the D.C. bill. Obama generally supports civil unions but has said marriage is between a man and a woman.

    "The march toward equality is coming to this country, and you can either be a part of it or stand in the way," said David Catania, one of two openly gay D.C. Council members.

    Barry, a longtime supporter of the gay community, called it an "agonizing and difficult decision" that he made after prayer and consulting with the religious community.

    Catania called the issue one of fundamental fairness. It's about acknowledging that his family is just as valid as anybody else's, he said.

    "The District has long been a place where we have tried to live under our motto of 'Justice for All,' and there is no justice so long as we recognize that some are more equal than others," he said.

    Gay-marriage supporters greeted the vote with applause, but they were outnumbered at city hall by outraged opponents, including many black ministers.

    The Rev. Anthony Evans, a pastor at Mount Zion Baptist Church in Washington, vowed to make sure the legislation dies in Congress and said he will work to unseat every D.C. Council member who voted for it.

    "They just kissed their political careers goodbye," he said.

    The congressional review could be the new Congress' first opportunity to signal its appetite for re-examining the Defense of Marriage Act, which bars federal recognition of same-sex marriages and allows states to do the same.

    U.S. Rep. Barney Frank, D-Mass., who is openly gay, said he expects Congressional opponents of gay marriage to rally to repeal the city's decision but doubts they'll get very far.

    "For this to be overturned, it'd have to pass both houses and be signed by the president, and that's highly unlikely," Frank said.

    An overflow crowd filled city hall ahead of the vote, and more than 100 opponents from churches in the Washington region held a rally across the street on Freedom Plaza.
     
    "Once you redefine marriage, you redefine family," said the Rev. Derek McCoy of the Hope Christian Church in Beltsville, Md.

    The ministers also held a wedding for a man and a woman from Fort Worth outside city hall.

    Gay marriage supporters gathered outside the council hearing room included Ed Grandis, a lawyer who lives in Dupont Circle with his husband, J.D. Campos. The pair married in California last year during the time same-sex marriage was legal there, and they hope to have their marriage recognized in D.C.

    "We don't have any interest in making their religious institution recognize our marriage or our relationship," Grandis said. Instead, Grandis said, it's about the government recognizing the couple's civil rights.

    The District already recognizes domestic partnerships, but gay marriage supporters said that's not enough.

    "It's an equality issue," said Sara Mindel, who has been with her partner for nine years and has a 10-month-old son. "In my mind, marriage, although it's a wonderful religious ceremony, ultimately gives you so many important states rights and legal rights."

    The vote is considered the first step toward eventually allowing gay marriages to be performed in Washington. Catania could introduce such a bill this year, and there's uncertainty about whether the same-sex marriage question could be put to D.C. voters, Craig reported.

    A Washington Post-ABC News poll found that 49 percent of voters nationwide support same-sex marriage, but only 42 percent of African-Americans supported it, and according to census data, the District is 55 percent black.

    Vermont, Connecticut, Massachusetts and Iowa already allow gay marriage and lawmakers in several other states are considering whether to do the same. New York recognizes gay marriages performed in other states.