An external audit conducted by a former attorney general of Virginia revealed Gov. Bob McDonnell did not give preferential treatment to Start Scientific or Rock Creek Pharmaceuticals, but did set up a meeting between company representatives and government employees.
Federal authorities continue to investigate whether McDonnell used the influence of his office to promote Star Scientific's anti-inflammatory supplement, Anatabloc, for Jonnie Williams and his company. They contributed more than $100,000 to McDonnell's political organizations and gave the governor's family personal gifts worth thousands of dollars.
Former Democratic Attorney General and current Richmond lawyer Tony Troy found "no public funds, grants or contracts" given to Williams or Star Scientific by government agencies. Troy, who is McDonnell's state-appointed lawyer, also stated he found "no gubernatorial appointments were made to either Williams or any other officer of Start Scientific or Rock Creek Pharmaceuticals" during the McDonnell administration.
McDonnell, who has hired a private team of attorneys, has categorically denied arranging any benefit for Williams. He has defended his decision not to list the personal gifts on his required annual statement of economic interest reports because state law compels only state officeholders, not family members, to disclose gifts. Virginia places no limit on the value of gifts officeholders receive.
Troy said his findings revealed three arranged meetings between Star Scientific representatives and "members of the governor's cabinet or their representatives" between 2010 and 2012. The results were the following, according to Troy:
- First meeting, in 2010, Williams met with Secretary of Health and Human Services, Dr. William Hazel. The Washington Post reported Wednesday McDonnell helped set up this meeting.
- Second meeting, in 2011, Williams met with Maureen McDonnell a Health and a Human Resources Senior Policy Advisor Molly Huffstetler
- Third meeting, in 2012, Star Scientific salesperson David Dean met with the Director of the Department of Human Resource Management Sara Wilson
In the first two meetings, Williams "made no direct requests for state benefits and Commonwealth officials promised none." In the third meeting, Dean wanted the Commonwealth to consider placing Anatabloc on a list of items available to state employees under their health plans. Troy says Wilson denied the request.
MORE ON NBCWASHINGTON.COM:
- Emails: McDonnell Set Up Williams's Cabinet Meeting
- McDonnell's Approval Hits Low Amid Scandal
- Virginia Ends Fiscal Year '13 With Another Surplus
- Judge Refuses to Dismiss Former Virginia Executive Mansion Chef's Case