Judge Rejects Request to Detain Migrant Families Long-Term - NBC4 Washington
Immigration in America

Immigration in America

Full coverage of immigration issues in the U.S.

Judge Rejects Request to Detain Migrant Families Long-Term

Three years ago, the same judge rejected a similar effort by the Obama administration



    Celebrating Life After Breast Cancer
    Spencer Platt/Getty Images, File
    In this June 24, 2018, file photo, a security guard checks cars at the entrance to Casa Padre, a former Walmart which is now a center for unaccompanied immigrant children in Brownsville, Texas.

    A California federal judge on Monday rejected the Trump administration's efforts to detain immigrant families for long terms, calling it a "cynical attempt" to undo a longstanding court settlement.

    U.S. District Judge Dolly Gee said the federal government had failed to present new evidence to support revising a court order that limits detaining children who crossed the border illegally for extended periods.

    The Department of Justice asked Gee to alter a 1997 settlement, which provides the framework for how to handle detained immigrant children, so it could detain families together for longer periods.

    The Trump administration said Gee's previous rulings had made family detention unlikely and provided an incentive for a surge of immigrants to bring children across the border illegally with the expectation they wouldn't be locked up.

    Gee called the administration's request "a cynical attempt" to shift responsibility to the court "for over 20 years of Congressional inaction and ill-considered executive action that have led to the current stalemate."

    Three years ago, Gee rejected a similar effort by the Obama administration. She ruled at the time that immigrant children generally can't be held longer than 20 days.

    More than 2,000 children were separated from their parents by U.S. immigration authorities at the border with Mexico this spring before President Donald Trump reversed course on June 20 amid an international outcry.

    The application to change the Flores agreement — named for an El Salvador immigrant who was 15 when the case was brought in 1985 — was "procedurally improper and wholly without merit," said Gee, who was nominated to the court by President Barack Obama.

    The Department of Justice was reviewing Monday's ruling and did not say if it would appeal.

    "We disagree with the court's ruling declining to amend the Flores Agreement to recognize the current crisis of families making the dangerous and unlawful journey across our southern border," spokesman Devin O'Malley said in a statement.

    Migrant Children Held at Fla. Detention Center 'Traumatized' By Separation

    [NATL-MI] Impact on Children Living in Detention Centers

    A lawyer for young migrant children at a Florida detention center says her clients, one as young as 3 years old, are traumatized by the forcible separation from family members. Attorneys say attempts to track down their parents have been unsuccessful. WTVJ's Marissa Bagg reports.

    (Published Thursday, June 21, 2018)

    Families can be detained together if their parents waive their right to release children to the custody of a family member.

    Attorney Peter Schey, who represents detained children in the settlement, said President Donald Trump had falsely claimed the settlement required the separation of families.

    "Sifting through the government's false narrative, the court clearly found that the Flores settlement has never resulted in the separation of families," Schey said. "President Trump needs to take responsibility for his own misguided policies."

    The ruling came the same day the government acknowledged it would not meet a Tuesday deadline set by a San Diego federal judge who ordered detained children under 5 to be reunited with their families.

    Justice Department lawyer Sarah Fabian said 54 of the 100 or so infants and toddlers covered by the order would be reunited on time. She said the delay for others was due to a variety of reasons, including that the parents of some of the youngsters had already been deported.

    U.S. District Judge Dana Sabraw, a nominee of Republican President George W. Bush, set a July 26 deadline to reunite all the children separated from their parents.

    Emotional NYC Reunion for Family Separated at Border

    [NATL-NY] Emotional NYC Reunion for Family Separated at Border

    NBC 4 was at the emotional scene in New York City after a mother was reunited with her children who were separated from her at the border.

    (Published Tuesday, July 3, 2018)

    The government had claimed in its filings that Sabraw's ruling trumped the Flores agreement. Gee rejected that argument on several grounds, saying the U.S. was relying on a "tortured interpretation" of the deal.

    Associated Press writer Elliot Spagat contributed to this story.