Pence's Indiana Record More Complicated Than Campaign Claims | NBC4 Washington
Decision 2016

Decision 2016

Full coverage of the race for the White House

Pence's Indiana Record More Complicated Than Campaign Claims

Pence is set to accept the GOP vice presidential nomination on Wednesday



    Getty Images
    Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump stands with his newly selected vice presidential running mate Mike Pence, governor of Indiana, at the end of an event at the Hilton Midtown Hotel, July 16, 2016, in New York City.

    The national rollout of Republican vice presidential candidate Mike Pence has touted the Indiana governor's record on jobs, tax cuts, infrastructure and school funding. 

    While many of the claims Donald Trump made about his running mate while introducing him Saturday are technically true, the context of the claims shows a more complicated picture of Indiana's economic picture under Pence.

    With Pence set to accept the GOP vice presidential nomination on Wednesday night, here's a closer look of some of the claims about his Indiana record:

    "Governor Pence enacted the largest income tax cut in the state's history." — Trump while introducing Pence on Saturday 

    Trump Will Honor Election Results 'If I Win'

    [NATL] Trump Will Honor Presidential Election Results 'If I Win'
    Speaking at a rally in Ohio on Oct. 20, 2016, Donald Trump said that he would accept the presidential election results if they were in his favor. "I would like to promise and pledge to all of my voters and supporters and to all the people of the United Staes that I will totally accept the results of this great and historic presidential election -- if I win,” Donald Trump said, emphasizing the last three words by pointing into the crowd. The rally was held the day following the final debate, during which the issue of whether he would accept the election results came up. At the debate, he said he would have to wait and see what the results were. (Published Thursday, Oct. 20, 2016)

    The individual income tax that the Republican-dominated Legislature approved at Pence's behest in 2013 is Indiana's largest ever, although it was modest and didn't have much competition for that mark. 

    Under Pence, the state's income tax rate dropped to 3.3 percent beginning in 2015 and will go to 3.23 percent beginning in January 2017. 

    The only previous income tax cut in state history was a 0.1 percentage point reduction in the 1970s, according to Purdue University economist Larry DeBoer, who has studied Indiana tax policy for about 30 years. That rate was raised during the 1980s to 3.4 percent — where it remained until Pence won the new cuts. 

    Whether the cuts do much to boost the Indiana economy is uncertain, DeBoer said. Someone with $50,000 in taxable income will see their previous state income tax bill of $1,700 drop by $85 a year when the cuts are fully in place. That will mean about an extra $3.50 a month starting in January. 

    Spencer Platt/Getty Images

    The Pence income tax cut amounts to an estimated $265 million in taxpayer savings this budget year, DeBoer said. 

    But it is far from the biggest tax cut in Indiana history as statewide caps on property taxes, which primarily fund local governments, are projected to save taxpayers about $800 million this year, according to DeBoer. Those were enacted under Pence's gubernatorial predecessor, Mitch Daniels.

    "Today, there are more Hoosiers going to work than ever before in the 200-year history of the great state of Indiana." — Pence at a July 12 Trump campaign rally in Indiana. 

    While that's true, the state's population also has reached record levels. The U.S. Census Bureau estimates Indiana's population has grown nearly 9 percent, or about 540,000 people, since 2000 to some 6.6 million residents in 2015.

    Trump: US Election Result Will Be 'Brexit Times Five'

    [NATL-PHI] Trump Rallies Voters in Bucks County
    Pennsylvania suburbs have become pivotal to both presidential candidates to win the election. NBC10's Aundrea Cline-Thomas has more from Donald Trump's rally in Bucks County. (Published Saturday, Oct. 22, 2016)

    Indiana's jobless rate was 8 percent when he took office in January 2013 and was 5 percent in May, the most recent month available. But that improvement started long before Pence became governor as Indiana's unemployment mark topped out at 10.9 percent in early 2010 amid the Great Recession. Indiana's jobless rate over that time has also largely paralleled the national mark, which was 4.7 percent in May.

    Pence said on Saturday that Indiana has made "record investments" in roads, and Trump touted a report by CNBC that ranked the state as first in the nation in infrastructure.

    In fact, improving Indiana's roads wasn't a priority of Pence's until it became a liability: a monthlong traffic snarl caused when an Interstate 65 bridge was closed last August for emergency repairs. 

    Motorists were detoured, traffic backed up and Democrats attacked. A brutal labor union-sponsored TV spot aired during an Indianapolis Colts game blaming a handful of roadway deaths on Pence's desire to build a budget surplus at the expense of properly funding infrastructure. 

    Trump, Clinton Trade Insults at Dinner

    [NATL-NY] Trump, Clinton Trade Insults at Dinner
    Bitter presidential rivals Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump had one more face-to-face showdown before Election Day. They tried to make it funny but plenty of the jokes bombed, and some even earned scattered boos. Watch each of the candidates' roasts in their entirety here. (Published Friday, Oct. 21, 2016)

    Weeks later, Pence proposed a road improvement plan that relied on borrowing, drawing down state reserves and accounting gimmicks to reach an advertised $1 billion sticker price. 

    In the end, he got just a fraction of that after Indiana's Republican-controlled Legislature balked. And much of the money set aside for local governments came from local taxes held in state reserves that were already supposed to be returned.

    "Under Governor Pence's leadership, Indiana enacted the largest K-12 education funding increase in the state's history." — Trump while introducing Pence on Saturday. 

    When simply looking at dollars, Indiana's current state budget does give the largest school funding increase. The two-year budget spends about $480 million more toward K-12 education. 

    Fact Check: Trump and Clinton's Debate Claims

    [NATL] Fact Check: Trump and Clinton's Debate Claims
    Donald Trump painted an inaccurately dark portrait of manufacturing in America while Hillary Clinton stretched credulity in boasting that her spending plans won't add to the country's debt. Associated Press writer Chris Rugaber breaks down those claims and more. (Published Thursday, Oct. 20, 2016)

    But that amounts to just a 2.3 percent increase for education. Between 2000 and 2008, the increase averaged about 2.7 percent a year — although the total dollars were much lower because local taxes covered a greater portion of school budgets at the time, DeBoer said.