Muzzles Spotlight Affronts to Free Speech

Virginia Department of Corrections "wins" for denying inmate a Christian sermon CD

The Thomas Jefferson Center for the Protection of Free Expression announced its 2010 Jefferson Muzzle awards.

This year all 10 โ€œwinnersโ€ were government and school officials, including the Virginia Department of Corrections.

An inmate requested a CD of a Christian sermon but was denied on the grounds that "you can only receive music CD's, no sermons on CD's."

The Alabama Alcohol Control Board won for banning the sale of a California wine because the label had a naked nymph riding a bike on the bottle. The questionable image is a replica of an 1895 French poster featuring a nymph flying next to a winged bicycle.

โ€œIf you magnify it by three or four-fold, even then you could barely detect a nipple,โ€ Center Director Bob Oโ€™Neil said.

Southwestern College in Chula Vista, Calif., won for its policy limiting protests to a free speech patio. Faculty members protesting budget cuts tried to move to a nearby courtyard but were banned from campus.

The Las Vegas Police Department won after it blocked musicians from performing on the main strip -- particularly those on streets, sidewalks and parks that are considered public space.

Oklahomaโ€™s tax commission won after it denied personalized license plate with the words โ€œIM GAY.โ€ The commission cited its rule barring plates that might be offensive to the general public.

Visit the Thomas Jefferson Center for the Protection of Free Expression Web site for a complete list of the winners.

Contact Us