Harris Clarifies Stance on Federally Mandated School Busing

Busing, while not central to the Democratic primary, has become a proxy issue for the debate between Biden and Harris over race as well as broader questions

Sen. Kamala Harris clarified her position on federally mandated school busing,  saying it's only necessary in cases where local governments are actively opposing integration.

As she spoke with reporters Thursday before a campaign event in Indianola, Iowa, Harris said that in the 1960s and '70s, institutions "were literally working against integration of our schools."

That's why she said she supported busing then but now thinks it should just be a "tool" available to local governments and school districts to address segregation.

"Today it is very rare that we require the courts or the federal government to intervene," Harris said. 

But Harris muddied the waters Wednesday when she told reporters she too did not support federally mandated busing and supported it only as an option for local governments.

On Wednesday, Harris said that busing students should be considered by school districts trying to desegregate their locations — not the federal mandate she appeared to support in pointedly criticizing rival Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden last week.

Her stance on busing came under scrutiny after last week's debate, when she went after former Vice President Joe Biden for his stance on busing while he was a senator.

Harris had a breakthrough moment at the candidates' first debate when she criticized Biden for his opposition to mandatory school busing when he was a senator in the 1970s. Harris said she benefited from busing as an elementary school student in Berkeley, California, in the early 1970s.

"That's where the federal government must step in," Harris said, looking at Biden and winning a burst of applause from the auditorium in Miami.

On Wednesday, though, Harris characterized busing as a choice local school districts have, not the responsibility of the federal government.

Busing, while not central to the Democratic primary, has become a proxy issue for the debate between Biden and Harris over race as well as broader questions about whether the 76-year-old former vice president is out of step with his party.

After a Democratic Party picnic Wednesday in West Des Moines, Harris was asked by reporters whether she supports federally mandated busing.

"I think of busing as being in the toolbox of what is available and what can be used for the goal of desegregating America's schools," she responded.

Asked to clarify whether she supports federally mandated busing, she replied, "I believe that any tool that is in the toolbox should be considered by a school district."

Harris' comments Wednesday were far from the indictment she delivered during the debate last week.

Under attack on the debate stage, Biden appeared stunned and dismissed Harris' comments as a mischaracterization of his positions. He has notably begun his remarks to fundraisers by talking about how civil rights spurred his entry into public life more than 45 years ago.

To be sure, Biden's record on busing is complicated.

Biden has insisted he only opposed busing ordered by the federal Education Department, and said allowing local governments and school districts to implement busing was "one of the things I argued for" at the time.

During an appearance at a conference last week in Chicago, Biden told the audience he "never, never, never, ever opposed voluntary busing."

But Biden was an outspoken opponent of federally mandated busing in the 1970s and '80s, sponsoring a congressional measure that would have limited funding for federal busing efforts.

On Thursday, Biden told reporters after seeing her latest comments that he believed the two agreed on the issue, and that he felt her critique had come out of nowhere.

Harris, however, told reporters "we do not agree," pointing to his past criticism of busing, and said she was surprised Biden was caught off-guard by her debate stage criticism. 

"Part of the impetus of the conversation was the statements that the Vice President made about his work with segregationists and that was the subject of conversation for days on end, so if he and his team weren't prepared for the topic I don't know what to say about that," she said.

The feud erupted as Harris enjoyed a surge in a number of post-debate polls and both she and Biden descended on Iowa for the Fourth of July holiday. Iowa is a key state for both candidates as they vie for the Democratic nomination.

The issue spilled into Iowa as Harris and Biden returned Wednesday for the first time since the debate. Both will need some success in Iowa's leadoff nominating caucuses to build momentum heading into South Carolina, the first Southern primary, where they are vying aggressively for a robust African American voting bloc.

Biden and Harris also have been aggressively courting members of the Congressional Black Caucus, with Harris edging Biden in endorsements, picking up support from Reps. Bobby Rush of Illinois and Frederica Wilson of Florida. Biden last week landed the support of popular Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms.

In Iowa, where African Americans are a small minority, endorsements from black leaders are magnified. Harris got the backing of two popular black ministers after her debate performance last week.

Appearing Wednesday evening in Waterloo, Iowa's most densely African American city, Biden received the backing of one of that city's most influential black ministers.

Copyright AP - Associated Press
Contact Us