The Howard University Faculty Senate threw its support behind student protesters who have occupied an administration building on campus for five days — and say they won't stop until their demands are met.
The senate condemned in a letter any action the administration has taken or could take in the future to call the police on students or forcibly remove them from the building.
Faculty are encouraged by and proud of the student's efforts, the letter read.
The letter supported the student's in several of their nine demands, but made no mention of the protester's call for Howard President Wayne Frederick to resign.
The protesting students say the school's President Wayne Frederick has not met with them to hear their demands and vowed to continue their demonstration.
Howard officials said in a tweet that the president has heard student concerns: "President Frederick met with students in the Louis Stokes library to hear their concerns and answer questions. Howard is committed to continuing an open dialogue with all students on campus. Town hall meetings forthcoming.".
Protesters acknowledge that Frederick met with some students in the university library, but protesters say the meeting was sprung on a select group of students who are not affiliated with the protest.
With tutoring, snacks and a farmer's market inside the occupied administration building, it appears protesting students are prepared to stay until the president meets with them.
Some members of the administration have spoken with protesters. But student Oluwatmi Leinbamgbola says the response hasn't been ideal.
"It's been kind of condescending," Leinbamgbola said.
Students have issued nine demands including adequate housing, disarming campus police, a tuition freeze and sexual assault reforms. Students also want Howard University President Wayne Frederick to resign.
"We're going to keep going until our demands are met and negotiations are finished," HU Resist student organizer Alexis McKenney said.
On the fourth day of protests on Sunday, trustees agreed to meet one demand by extending a housing deadline.
Vice President of Student Affairs Kenneth M. Holmes said in an email Sunday that the deadline for students to submit a $200 housing deposit has been extended to May 1.
"If this extension results in a significant number of students requesting on campus housing, we will delay the Quad renovation in order to accommodate the additional occupancy,” the email said.
Howard's administration will also examine its policy requiring freshman and students under age 21 to live on campus or live at home with a parent or guardian and they will measure the policy against bed availability, according to the email.
The agreement on housing was reached after students met with board members for about four hours on Saturday.
It's not clear if student protesters will be exempted for missing classes.
"We are carrying on the tradition of Howard, the tradition of activism, the tradition of resistance to oppression and the university should recognize that," McKenney said.
Twenty-six faculty members sent a letter of support to the students late Sunday, The Hilltop reported.
"You should be aware that we and many other faculty members share many of your concerns. Please feel free to reach out to us for support," the letter said.
Minutes later, the university's alumni association sent a letter rejecting the students' demands for Frederick to step down and stating its support of the president.
"Under our current Administration, our Alumni have led over 250 college fairs, recruited thousands of students to the University, and provided over $250,000 in scholarships. We will proudly continue to do so, even in the light of the recent financial aid revelation," read part of the letter signed by HUAA President Nadia Pinto.
Pinto went on to say that Frederick and the trustees would "create the necessary controls to prevent fraudulent behavior" and an initial report of findings of the financial aid investigation is expected to be released to alumni and students on April 6.
McKenney said the sit-in wasn't just about protesting, but demonstrating a model for what they want the university to be. Students have hosted activities inside the administration building including tutoring, counseling, art classes, lectures and healing spaces. They also met with organizers of a 1989 Howard protest to learn strategy and tactics of a successful demonstration.
Sunday morning, Howard's Dean of the Chapel led a nondemoninational Easter service for students in the administration building.
"The negotiations have been productive and collectively, the Board of Trustees is extremely impressed with the way that the students have handled the negotiations," Rock Newman, an alumni board member, said Saturday.
The student-led protest began Thursday afternoon in response to Frederick's announcement that six employees were fired last year after an internal investigation found the financial aid office had misappropriated university-based grants to some university employees.
"We are here because we love Howard University. We're here because we want to improve the conditions of everybody that goes to this school," student organizer Juan Demetrixx said Saturday.
Although the students said they were making progress with the trustees, the protest continued after their meeting.
"We're hoping that within the next coming days, we're able to get these demands met," Demetrixx said.
On Friday, students met with two trustees, but said the meeting was unsuccessful and the trustees had not read their demands.
"We wanted to initiate negotiations, but they made it very clear that many of the board of trustee members - despite the email going out saying that our demands were inaccurate and essentially unsubstantiated - that many of them have not even read our demands," McKenney said.
Frederick responded in a statement to several of the demands, reiterating current policies and promising to review deficiencies. He invited students to provide feedback on a sexual harassment policy and promised to form a public safety advisory committee.
He also said that every student who registered their request for housing on time received an assignment. Protesters claim that about 500 other students haven't received housing despite a guarantee and requirement that first- and second-year students live on campus.
"Your concerns are valid. We are listening. We are committed to jointly making changes to move Howard Forward," the statement said.
McKenney said Sunday the president has not reached out to the student organizers.
"He's been silent. He's not expressed any desire to meet with us at all. And I think that sends a big message as to how exactly he's responded to students."
Twenty faculty members wrote a letter in support of Frederick, saying they believe his leadership offers students' best chance to implement their proposed changes.
The organizers of the sit-in at the building housing the president's office and the financial aid office put up signs over the building's doors detailing their demands. Those demands were also posted to social media:
The signs also said the building is closed to anyone except students and cleaning staff.
Howard junior Viennetta Davis said a survey showed the overwhelming majority of students don't think the administration cares about them and that Frederick's leadership was lacking.
"This is a feeling that's been brewing for awhile," Davis said. "This isn't a spur of the moment thing."
Students had already publicly listed their demands after a string of other issues on campus. In March, Frederick drew criticism for his response to a student who begged him for help securing housing. He told her the "tone and tenor" of her email were inappropriate. In January, spring semester classes were delayed by more than a week because of campus-wide problems with the heating system. And last May, students filed a lawsuit saying the university failed to help students who were raped by fellow students and employees.
Howard Employees Accused of Pocketing Financial Aid Dollars
According to a statement from Frederick, an outside auditor found several university employees received grants in addition to discounts on tuition that exceeded the total cost of tuition and kept the difference.
Some students said they felt betrayed. Employees took financial aid funds as students prepare to spend years paying off their loans.
Frederick said he was told in December 2016 that there may have been "some misappropriation of university-provided financial aid funds," and launched an internal investigation.
The auditor found that between 2007 and 2016, university grants were awarded to some university employees who also were receiving tuition remission. The grants and tuition remission equaled more than the total cost of attendance, which allowed the employees to receive "inappropriate refunds."
The grants came from institutional funds that help low-income students pay tuition. Frederick said the grants came from the university and were not federal or donor funds.
Tuition remission allows eligible employees or their dependents to receive discounted tuition at the university. Full-time employees eligible to receive tuition remission can take two classes per semester for free, according to the university's website. Tuition at Howard for the 2017-2018 school year was $12,061 per semester, not including room and board.
Frederick's statement came after an anonymous post on Medium.com claimed financial aid employees at the university stole nearly $1 million in funds. The post has since been removed.
Frederick did not comment on how much had been received by those individuals.
Frederick said the issue was reported to the Department of Education in July 2017, and six employees were fired two months later for "gross misconduct and neglect of duties."
Student protests stepped up after the revelations, but Chairman Stacey Mobley wrote on behalf of the university's Board of Trustees that they stand by Frederick's leadership.
"All of us recognize the critical role financial aid plays in the lives of our students and it was important to us to ensure the office was operating appropriately," the letter read. "While the review unfortunately uncovered alarming behavior, [Frederick] immediately took appropriate action and launched an internal investigation to get to the bottom of this."
Fifty years ago this month, another Howard class made history by taking over the administration building to protest a curriculum that lacked courses on African-American history, culture and pride.
Read Frederick's full statement below:
Statement from Wayne A. I. Frederick, President of Howard University
In accordance with my commitment to continuous progress, in February 2015, I initiated a proactive review of the Howard University Office of Financial Aid to ensure the office was providing the best support to our campus community.
As part of this process, I was alerted in December 2016 that there may have been some misappropriation of University-provided financial aid funds. From the moment I was alerted that there may have been a misappropriation of funds, I have taken this situation extremely seriously. I immediately informed the Board of Trustees, and together we moved swiftly to begin an internal investigation. The University immediately engaged an outside auditor (RSM) to determine whether there had been any misappropriation of Howard University funds by staff in the Office of Financial Aid or elsewhere, and if so, the magnitude of that misappropriation. The auditors completed their investigation and reported the results to me in May 2017.
The investigation found that from 2007 to 2016, University grants were given to some University employees who also received tuition remission. The audit revealed that the combination of University grants and tuition remission exceeded the total cost of attendance. As a result, some individuals received inappropriate refunds. Note that University grants are institutional funds used to help support students with student charges. They are not federal funds or donor directed funds.
In July 2017, I self-reported this issue to the Department of Education and assured them we would provide regular updates on the investigation.
An investigation of individual employee actions was completed in September 2017 and as a result, six employees have been fired for gross misconduct and neglect of duties. We will refer this matter for criminal prosecution, as appropriate.
Third Coast Higher Education, another outside expert, was also brought in specifically to determine if any misappropriation of federal funds occurred. At this point, Third Coast found no misappropriation of federal funds related to this issue.
The financial integrity of Howard University’s operations is paramount and strong measures have been taken following the RSM investigation to ensure this never happens again. As part of these reform efforts, significant new policies and procedures have been implemented to strengthen Howard’s internal controls with respect to the awarding of financial aid, including:
• Annual budgets for each category of financial aid are now loaded into the University’s Banner student information system by the University Budget Office consistent with the University’s overall Financial Aid Budget.
• Approval for all awards of University Grants are now reviewed and approved by the Budget Office prior to being awarded by the Financial Aid Office
• Approval for all donor-designated scholarship awards are now reviewed and approved by the Controller’s Office prior to being awarded by the Financial Aid Office.
• Approval for all grant-funded financial aid are now reviewed and approved by the University’s Grant Accounting Unit prior to being awarded by the Financial Aid Office.
• Access to the Banner financial aid module has now been limited to a small number of appropriate senior University individuals, with adequate third-party review and appropriate segregation of duties.
• An annual reconciliation of awarded financial aid to approved financial aid is now being conducted.
• Management has established proper reporting relationships and segregation of duties within the Financial Aid Office.
• Management is in the process of hiring for all remaining open positions in the Financial Aid Office and enhanced training on policies and procedures will be provided both to new hires and continuing employees.
• A new Associate Provost for Enrollment Management and a new Chief Compliance Officer have been hired by the University.
While this has been a very difficult and disappointing situation, I know our campus community deserves better and I am committed to ensuring that each of our campus offices operate with integrity and are the best that higher education has to offer.