George W. Bush shed a sentimental tear. Barack Obama mused about the burdens of the office. Bill Clinton dished out wisecracks. Jimmy Carter and George H.W. Bush chimed in, too, on a rare day of harmony at the dedication of the younger Bush's presidential library that glossed over the hard edges and partisan divides of five presidencies spanning more than three tumultuous decades.
"To know the man is to like the man,'' Obama declared of his Republican predecessor, speaking Thursday before a crowd of 10,000 at an event that had the feel of a class reunion for the partisans who had powered the Bush administration from 2001 to 2009. Dick Cheney was there in a white cowboy hat. Condoleezza Rice gave shout-outs to visiting dignitaries. Colin Powell and Karl Rove were prominent faces in the crowd.
On this day, there was no mention of Iraq or Afghanistan, the wars that dominated Bush's presidency and so divided the nation. There were only gentle references to the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. And praise aplenty for the resolve that Bush showed in responding to the 9/11 terror attacks.
Instead, the day was about the legacy preserved in the new Presidential Center. Laura Bush led the library's design committee, with a keen eye toward ensuring that not only Bush's presidency, but the family's roots and values, were reflected.
Laura Bush told News4's Barbara Harrison in an one-on-one interview that with exhibits such as "Living in the White House," she wanted to give visitors a small taste of the First Family's experience, because "everyone wants to know what it's like to live here."
Gifts to the Bushes are displayed, including a sapphire and diamond necklace and earring set given to Laura by King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia.
"People might not know, but gifts that come from foreign heads of state are considered gifts to the people of the United States," Laura Bush said. "And so we never owned them, they weren't ours. They are here now for people to see."
But the library also reflects the Bush's roots in Texas. Architects used local materials, including Texas Cordova cream limestone and trees from the central part of the state, in its construction.
"I wanted it to have the Texas feel that this building does because that's where we're from,'' Laura Bush told The Associated Press. "I also wanted the building to be modern-looking, to be forward-looking because George was president during the very first decade of our new century.''
Architect Robert A.M. Stern says the former first lady influenced the design throughout the project.
"She has a very good eye,'' Stern said. "She gives the architect his own space and then let's the architect present his ideas, at least this architect. And then she thinks about it. Sometimes she speaks directly at the time and sometimes she ... sleeps on it and we talk later. But it's been a very productive and rewarding process from my point of view.''
And the museum includes an exhibit on the 9/11 terror attacks that shaped George Bush's second term, including steel beams from the World Trade Center.
Not always easy, not always popular
Clinton joked that the dedication of the George W. Bush Presidential Center was "the latest, grandest example of the eternal struggle of former presidents to rewrite history.'' But he also praised Bush for including interactive exhibits at the center that invite visitors to make their own choices on major decisions that he faced.
Bush, 66, made indirect reference to the polarizing decision points of his presidency, drawing a knowing laugh as he told the crowd: "One of the benefits of freedom is that people can disagree. It's fair to say I created plenty of opportunities to exercise that right.''
He said he was guided throughout his presidency by a determination "to expand the reach of freedom.''
"It wasn't always easy, and it certainly wasn't always popular.''
It was a day for family and sentimentality, Bush choking up with emotion at the conclusion of his remarks.
The 43rd president singled out his 88-year-old father, another ex-president, to tell him: "41, it is awesome that you are here today.''
The elder Bush, wearing jaunty pink socks, spoke for less than a minute from his wheelchair, then turned to his son and quipped, "Too long?'' He has a form of Parkinson's disease and has been hospitalized recently for bronchitis.
Just as the public tends to view presidents more kindly once they've left office, ex-presidents, too, tend to soften their judgments -- or at least their public comments -- with time.
Obama once excoriated Bush for his "failed policies'' and "disastrous'' handling of the economy, for expanding budget deficits, and for drawing the nation into war in Iraq.
On Thursday, he took a detour around those matters and instead praised Bush for his strength after 9/11, compassion in fighting HIV/AIDS in Africa, bipartisanship in pursuing education reforms and restarting "an important conversation by speaking with the American people about our history as a nation of laws and a nation of immigrants.''
If the country is eventually able to enact immigration changes this year, Obama added, "it will be, in large part, thanks to the hard work of President George W. Bush.''
Obama said the living presidents make up an exclusive club -- but it's more like a support group for the men who have held the position.
"No matter how much you may think you are ready to assume the office of the presidency, it's impossible to truly understand the nature of the job until it's yours,'' Obama said. "And that's why every president gains a greater appreciation for all of those who served before them.''
Keeping a low profile
The other presidents struck a similar tone.
Clinton praised Bush for his efforts to combat AIDS in Africa, his work on global health and even for the paintings he's doing in retirement. And he said he'd gotten so close to the Bush family that there were jokes that "I had become the black sheep son.''
Carter praised Bush for his role in helping secure peace between North and South Sudan in 2005 and the "great contributions you've made to the most needy people on earth.''
Bush has kept a decidedly low profile since leaving office four years ago with an approval rating of just 33 percent. That figure has been gradually climbing and now is at 47 percent -- about equal to Obama's own approval rating, according to a Washington Post-ABC News poll released ahead of the library opening.
If politics was absent from the podium on Thursday, it was still a prominent subtext.
Those in attendance included a number of potential candidates for president in 2016 -- another Clinton (Hillary) and Bush (Jeb) among them.
George W. Bush in recent days played up the idea of his younger brother, the former governor of Florida, seeking the White House, telling C-SPAN, "My first advice is: Run.''
Their mother, former first lady Barbara Bush, did the opposite.
"We've had enough Bushes,'' she said Thursday on NBC's "Today'' show.
The presidential center at Southern Methodist University includes a library, museum and policy institute. It contains more than 70 million pages of paper records, 200 million emails, 4 million digital photos and 43,000 artifacts. Bush's library will feature the largest digital holdings of any of the 13 presidential libraries under the auspices of the National Archives and Records Administration.
A full-scale replica of the Oval Office as it looked during Bush's tenure sits on the campus, as does a piece of steel from the World Trade Center and the bullhorn that Bush used to punctuate the chaos at ground zero three days after 9/11. In the museum, visitors can gaze at a container of chads -- the remnants of the famous Florida punch card ballots that played a pivotal role in the contested 2000 election that sent Bush to Washington.