If there was one takeaway from Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell's speech Wednesday night, it was this: He's no Bobby Jindal.
While there are few in this country who can go toe-to-toe with President Barack Obama on the speech circuit, McDonnell held his own and may have even advanced his political career by giving the Republican response to Obama's State of the Union Address.
With perfectly cropped hair, a voice strong and plenty of planted support around him in Richmond, McDonnell told the nation that it cannot afford the spending Democrats have enacted or the tax increases they propose.
McDonnell said Democratic policies are resulting in an unsustainable level of debt. He said Americans want affordable health care, but they don't want the government to run it.
"Today, the federal government is simply trying to do too much," McDonnell said. "In the past year, over 3 million Americans have lost their jobs, yet the Democratic Congress continues deficit spending, adding to the bureaucracy, and increasing the national debt on our children and grandchildren."
McDonnell said that all Americans want affordable, high-quality health care. But, he added, "Most Americans do not want to turn over the best medical care system in the world to the federal government."
McDonnell was chosen by national GOP leaders after he was elected in a rout last fall in a state Obama and the Democrats swept in 2008.
Republicans are feeling emboldened following a string of GOP victories at the polls, including a stunning win by Republican Scott Brown last week in a special Senate election in Massachusetts. Since then, Obama has amped up his populist rhetoric and promised a renewed focus on job creation.
Republicans said they want Obama to change more than his rhetoric. They complain that a $787 billion economic stimulus package enacted last year did not do enough to increase employment. And they oppose Obama's plan to let income tax cuts expire next year for families making more than $250,000 a year.
"We want results, not rhetoric," McDonnell said. "We want cooperation, not partisanship."
House Minority Leader John Boehner, R-Ohio, said, "This isn't about a pivot in terms of his message. I think that most Americans know that actions speak louder than words."
Democrats countered that much of the nation's debt is a result of economic policies enacted when Republicans controlled the federal government. Obama said he had cut income taxes, rather than increasing them, since taking office a year ago.
"Gov. McDonnell is a quick study," said Brad Woodhouse, communications director for the Democratic National Committee. "It took less than two full weeks in office for Bob McDonnell to adopt the national Republican Party's partisan rhetoric and to learn and repeat one falsehood after another about the president and his plans for the country."
McDonnell's speech was staged to look like a smaller version of a State of the Union address. He spoke from the historic Virginia House of Delegates before an audience of about 300 friends, family, supporters and members of his administration. The audience cheered when McDonnell entered the chamber, and applauded throughout his 13-minute speech.
In his remarks, McDonnell cited several areas of agreement with the president. On education, he said he agrees with Obama's proposal to increase the number of charter schools.
On national defense, he said he agrees with Obama's plan send an additional 30,0000 troops to Afghanistan. McDonnell said his oldest daughter, Jeanine, was an Army platoon leader in Iraq.
However, McDonnell said, Republicans have "serious concerns" about the administration's treatment of suspected terrorists. He complained that a Nigerian man accused of trying to blow up a plane as it approached Detroit on Christmas Day "was given the same legal rights as a U.S. citizen, and immediately stopped providing critical intelligence."
Some Republicans want suspected terrorists tried in military courts rather than civilian ones.
In a new twist for Republicans, Rep. Mario Diaz-Balart, R-Fla., taped a Spanish-language version of the Republican response carried by Spanish-language media.