Cuccinelli: State Can Regulate Abortion Clinics

View Comments ()
|
Email
|
Print

    NEWSLETTERS

    Getty Images
    WASHINGTON - OCTOBER 06: A ball of used tape with the word "LIFE" printed on it rests on top of a Bible in front of the Supreme Court on the first day of the court's new term October 6, 2008 in Washington, DC. About 20 demostrators gathered at the court to mark "Pro-Life Memorial Day 2008," an event sponsored by American Life League and several other organization. (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

    Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli has released another controversial and politically charged opinion -- this time on abortion -- which seems to have become the norm since the Republican took office in January.

    State government can oversee abortion providers in Virginia, much as it already regulates outpatient surgery centers, Cuccinelli said in an advisory opinion.

    Tougher Standards at Va. Abortion Clinics

    [DC] Tougher Standards at Va. Abortion Clinics
    Virginia's attorney general wants to impose tougher regulations at abortion clinics. (Published Tuesday, Aug 24, 2010)

    Cuccinelli's legal advice, issued Friday, could arm state agencies under a conservative governor with powers over abortion
    clinics that the General Assembly has refused to enact every year since the early 1980s.

    Attorney generals' opinions are not legally binding, as court rulings are. State and local officials use them for guidance in
    administering state policy and in forming legislation.

    But on Monday, Del. Robert G. Marshall of Prince William, one of two outspoken legislative opponents of abortion rights who had
    sought Cuccinelli's opinion on clinic regulations, asked Gov. Bob McDonnell to swiftly implement Cuccinelli's findings. McDonnell is
    a fellow Republican and abortion foe.

    The other, state Sen. Ralph Smith of Roanoke, wrote last week that the opinion "sets the stage for regulating abortion clinics
    like other medical facilities."

    McDonnell chief spokesman J. Tucker Martin said the governor had just received the opinion and is reviewing it, but noted that
    McDonnell believes abortion clinics should be regulated as outpatient surgery facilities already are.

    Cuccinelli, a staunch abortion foe, wrote that the definition of a hospital also encompasses facilities where first-trimester
    abortions are performed.

    His opinion reasoned that the state can regulate medical and safety conditions in abortion clinics as long the actions don't
    undermine court decisions protecting a woman's legal right to abortions, including the Supreme Court's 1973 Roe v. Wade decision.

    "This is basically an effort to use his executive power to push through a political agenda that he was unable to achieve through
    the democratic process," said Tarina Keene, executive director of NARAL Pro-Choice Virginia, an abortion rights advocacy group.
    Jessica Honke, the director of public policy at Planned Parenthood Advocates of Virginia, said she agrees that Virginia can
    regulate all medical facilities, including abortion clinics.

    "But if they use the opinion to impose an agenda that singles out one medical procedure that interferes with women's rights to
    health care, we will have objections to that," she said.

    It was the most recent in a series of controversial and politically charged opinions and legal actions by the socially conservative Republican attorney general since he took office in January.

    In March, an opinion said that college administrators could not enact policies protecting gay students or faculty from discrimination, and he sued the federal government over health reforms days after they became law. He also launched an investigation into whether former University of Virginia professor Michael Mann's research into climate change defrauded taxpayers.

    In Friday's opinion, Cuccinelli notes that there is no requirement to perform abortions during the first three months of a pregnancy in a hospital. Instead, they can be performed in what reproductive services providers characterize as "physicians' offices," exempting them from Board of Health licensing requirements.

    "Nevertheless, the Board has broad authority to adopt regulations as may be necessary to carry out (state law), and this regulatory authority includes defining an 'abortion clinic,' investigating an assertion by a facility that it constitutes a physician's office,' and regulating facilities beyond licensure," Cuccinelli wrote.

    But he also asserts an equally broad authority by the Board of Medicine, including "the ability to license, investigate, and discipline physicians, including those who perform abortions."

    Among the Board of Medicine's regulatory and oversight prerogatives, he said, are the proper administering of anesthesia outside of hospital settings.

    Cuccinelli cites a decision by the Richmond-based 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upholding South Carolina's regulations "addressing medical and safety aspects of providing abortions, as well as the recordkeeping and administrative practices of abortion clinics," including those performing first-trimester abortions.

    The extent to which McDonnell will accept Cuccinelli's guidance was unclear Monday. The governor compiled a socially conservative
    record in the General Assembly and as attorney general from 2006 until last year.

    Martin's e-mailed response to an The Associated Press inquiry suggests that tighter regulations are on the way.

    "The governor is a longstanding supporter of ensuring that abortion clinics, and their medical personnel, are treated equally with other out-patient surgical hospitals by the Commonwealth to ensure services are provided in a safe manner," Martin wrote.