NBC Washington /

News

Tyler Perry Sued For Copyright Infringement

Updated 10:48 AM EDT, Wed, Dec 3, 2008

Related Topics: Donna West | Tyler Perry

7 Comments   Post a comment Post a Comment

 

Tyler Perry went to court to face allegations that he stole material from someone else for his blockbuster film “Diary of a Mad Black Woman.”

Donna West is suing the actor-screenwriter for copyright infringement in U.S. District Court and wants a jury to award her family all profits made from the film.

MORE ACCESS ON THESE TOPICS: Lawsuits - Courts - Movies - Authors - TV One

“I can’t put my play on because the stories are basically the same and nobody wants to see that again,” she said.

West testified Tuesday that she developed a script titled “Fantasy of a Black Woman” based primarily on her own experiences. With her in the starring role, the play was performed in July 1991 at the Junior Black Academy of Arts and Letters at the Dallas Convention Center.

“The play was opened to the public. Anyone could have attended,” West said.

Perry’s movie, which earned some $50 million, came out in 2005. Jurors on Tuesday watched the film and listened to a reading of the script from West’s play.

In her opening remarks to the jury, Perry’s attorney, Veronica Lewis, said her client is an “immensely talented” individual “who has no need whatsoever” to use the materials of others.

Lewis noted that Perry had experienced considerable success before and after the film, “so why would he need to copy Ms. West’s script?”

Testimony was expected to resume Wednesday. U.S. District Judge Leonard Davis told jurors he anticipates the case will be completed by next Tuesday.

Copyright Access Hollywood

Comments (7)

Sort by: Most Recent | Oldest
  • L. Monday, Dec 29 at 1:36 PM FLAG COMMENT maybe she has a case. Just because he's talented does'nt mean he didn't see her script and figure it was so long ago no one would notice. he also knows that he can take what he saw, flip it a few times, throw his brilliance in and make a master piece. He's a brilliant writer for Goodness sakes. But God will seperate the truth from the lie.
  • YOUNG_PHILLY_LADY Friday, Dec 5 at 11:42 AM FLAG COMMENT neothe1 Thursday, Dec 4 at 9:04 AMb You must have not seen a Family that Preys.. And anyway Hollywood has been doing it for years with caucasian people... lets be for real...
  • Confused? Thursday, Dec 4 at 10:47 AM FLAG COMMENT This does not make any sense. His play Diary of a Mad Black Woman came out a long time before the movie did in fact years before. So how is he stealing her ideas? I remember watchin that play years ago when i was in hig school about 8 years ago. If she wanted to sue she should have when he had the succes from his play first. SHe needs to do her research before she tries to take any money from him.
  • neothe1 Thursday, Dec 4 at 9:04 AM FLAG COMMENT Tyler Perry movies need to be more ethnically diverse, I personally don't agree with the way he socially isolates African-americans in all of his movies
  • Jessica Wednesday, Dec 3 at 8:39 PM FLAG COMMENT some people are just so money hungry. I have been writing dramatic love stories like his before his movie came out, am I bitc*in? Many women live the tale of thecharacter in that movie! Please! Life is its own public reality, who needs a play that was on stage almost 18 years ago to make a movie that represents what women still go through today!? I agree, it is like crayon drawings! so childish!

Post a Comment

Name


Comment - You have 2000 characters left

Enter both words below, separated by a space, in the field located to the lower right. Can't read the words below? Try different words or an audio captcha. What's this?